Cakes, Cookies & Custom Desserts
At Fire & Frosted, every dessert tells a story- whether it’s a whimsicial birthday cake, a dozen just-because cookes, or a sweet centerpiece for your next celebration.
We specialize in handcrafted cakes, cupcakes, cookies and all things frosted. We love bringing your vision to life. Have a creative idea? We’re all ears. Want 50 cupcakes for your child’s birthday with zero fuss? That’s us.
Let’s bake something unforgettable. Submit the interest form to get started!
Made to Order Flavors (or bring your own!)
Cookies
Salted Vanilla Toffee - (a fan favorite!) Sweet and salty magic, with bits of buttery toffee and a hint of vanilla in every bite
Chocolate Chip - An elevated classic with gooey chocolate throughout
S’mores Campfire - Chocolate chip base loaded with mini marshmallows and graham cracker crusts
Nutella & Sea Salt Swirl - Chocolate hazelnut spread folded into a soft cookie dough, finished with a sprinkle of salt.
Soft Cinnamon Snickerdoodle - Classic chewy cookie rolled in cinnamon-sugar, made extra tender, cozy and nostalgic
Funfetti Birthday Cookie - Vanilla sugar cookie base loaded with rainbow sprinkles and white chocolate chips. Chewy, colorful and totally celebratory
Peanut Butter & Jelly Swirl - Peanut butter cookie with a swirl of raspberry jam - sweet, salty and perfect
Cupcakes
These are some of our favorite flavors!
Lemon Blueberry - Bright and zesty lemon cake bursting with juicy blueberries, topped with a swirl of tangy cream cheese frosting
Vanilla Bean with Raspberry Jam - Vanilla bean cake filled with a tart raspberry jam center, crowned with a silky vanilla buttercream
Vanilla Bliss - Soft, fluffy vanilla cake infused with real vanilla bean, topped with a dreamy vanilla buttercream and absolute bliss in every bite
Carrot Cake - Moist, gently spiced carrot cake topped with a tangy brown sugar cream cheese swirl
Peanut Butter & Fudge - Chocolate fudge cupcake with a peanut butter core, topped with peanut butter buttercream and mini chocolate chips
Cinnamon Roll Cupcake - Cinnamon-swirled vanilla cake with cream cheese glaze frosting - brunch in a dessert!
Blackberry Lemonade - Lemon cupcake with blackberry jam filling and a swirled blackberry-lemon buttercream
Our cookies are made in small batches using real ingredients—no shortcuts, no preservatives, just seriously good cookies. Each order includes 12 generously sized cookies, perfect for sharing (or not).
Choose from rotating seasonal flavors or one of our signature classics, like:
Salted Vanilla Toffee – buttery, sweet, and a little salty
S’mores – melty chocolate, toasted marshmallow, and graham
Chocolate Chip – crisp edges, soft centers, and a pinch of sea salt
🎁 Packaged for freshness and ready to gift, serve, or stash away for a late-night treat.
📍 Local delivery only (within Delaware)
🗓 Minimum 3 days’ notice required for custom orders
💬 Want a special combo or themed packaging? Add a note at checkout—we’ll be in touch!